Mandate a Federal Constitutional Carry Act

Liberty
,
1

Introduction:
The right to bear arms, as enshrined in the Second Amendment, has often been debated in terms of its scope and application, particularly concerning the carrying of firearms in public spaces. This policy proposal advocates for a unified national policy on firearms carry, aiming to streamline regulations by allowing for permitless carry across all states.

Policy Proposal:

I. Purpose:

  • To standardize gun carry laws across the United States, ensuring that citizens’ Second Amendment rights are uniformly recognized and protected without jurisdictional disparities.

II. Key Provisions:

  • Universal Permitless Carry:

    • Concealed and Open Carry: All U.S. citizens and legal residents over the age of 18 (or 21, in alignment with federal law for purchasing handguns) may carry concealed or open firearms without any permit or license requirement.

  • Preemption of State Laws:

    • This federal law will preempt any state or local laws that require a permit for carrying firearms, whether concealed or openly. States may still regulate the manner of carry (e.g., open vs. concealed) but cannot mandate permits.

  • Exceptions and Prohibitions:

    • Individuals prohibited by federal law from possessing firearms (e.g., felons, those with certain mental health adjudications, etc.) are excluded from this right.
    • States retain the authority to enforce laws regarding where firearms may not be carried (e.g., schools, government buildings, private property with no firearms signs).

  • Training and Safety:

    • While not mandating training for carry, this act encourages states and private organizations to offer voluntary training courses on firearm safety and legal responsibilities.

  • Reciprocity and Enforcement:

    • The act ensures that the recognition of the right to carry is consistent across state lines, removing the patchwork of reciprocity agreements.
    • Enforcement would involve standardizing the understanding of what constitutes legal carry, focusing on compliance with federal firearm possession laws.

III. Implementation:

  • Legislative Action:

    • This policy would require federal legislation to override state gun carry laws, possibly through an amendment to the Gun Control Act or a standalone bill.

  • Phase-In Period:

    • Allow a transition period (e.g., 6 months to 1 year) for states to align their laws with the federal standard, ensuring law enforcement and the public are educated on the new regulations.

  • Public Awareness Campaign:

    • Launch a national campaign to inform citizens about their rights and responsibilities under the new carry laws, emphasizing safety, legality, and social responsibility.

IV. Considerations and Potential Challenges:

  • Legal Challenges:

    • Expect lawsuits from states or cities that oppose permitless carry, potentially leading to Supreme Court review.

  • Public Safety Concerns:

    • Address concerns by reinforcing existing federal background check systems and penalties for misuse of firearms.

  • Cultural and Political Resistance:

    • Different regions of the U.S. have varying attitudes towards gun control. Managing this diversity while implementing a uniform law will require sensitive political navigation.

V. Conclusion:

The National Permitless Carry Act aims to harmonize the exercise of Second Amendment rights across the nation, promoting a more unified approach to personal liberty while respecting the federal framework of government. By ensuring that legal, responsible adults can carry for self-defense without undue bureaucratic hurdles, this policy seeks to both affirm constitutional rights and enhance personal security. However, it must be balanced with robust education on firearm safety, clear laws on prohibited places, and stringent enforcement against those who would misuse these freedoms.

8 Likes
2

There are alot of older adults that have been convicted of nonviolent felonies. More then 20 yrs. Please change laws so these law abiding citizen can gun hunt or defend thier homes. So many have been productive members of society for many yrs after doing something stupid, should they suffer for this for the rest of thier lives? Those who have lived within the law for decades should be given this right back.n

7 Likes
3

I don’t believe non-violent felons should lose their right to vote or their right to a firearm.

6 Likes
4

You’re right. Restoring Firearm Rights and Voting Rights for Non-Violent Felons

2 Likes
5

I agree except for the Exceptions and Prohibitions section.

2 Likes
6

I do have some concern with red flag laws and the incursion of the state into people’s lives charged with misdemeanors.

I think there’s a reasonable argument to be made addressing concerns of banning guns in public buildings.

It does seem unconstitutional on its’ face.

2 Likes
7

I disagree with this as well. We’ve learned from Maryland and New York that state legislatures are incapable of “playing nice” with the 2nd Amendment. This also supposes the idea of banning carry on military installations as well. This would be better read as:
o the many States retain the authority to enforce all, currently precedent abiding, laws regarding where firearms may, or may not, be carried; the many States may not create or amend any law that restricts the rights of any citizen or legal resident to carry in any open and public place or facility.

Thoughts?

3 Likes
8

Society would get real polite real quick! We should also consider National Security and require everyone to carry a minimum of 3 days a week a 10 mm and for those that don’t own one or don’t have the means to purchase one and the rounds the government should be required for everybody over the age of 16 years to provide a 10 mm with 50,000 rounds, and a backup 10 mm a .375 with 50,000 rounds a 22 rifle of course with 50,000 rounds and then a couple other rifles of their choosing.
They’re 3 days of carrying should be marked on the driver’s license you have to carry on Monday Wednesday and Friday or you have to carry on this Sunday Tuesday Thursday and Saturday or you can carry everyday. They should be required to teach a Full semester of gun safety and maintenance and use. As well as head across the fence properly with one.

1 Like
9

I agree. I hate that when I travel I cannot have my gun on me in all states. I am a law-abiding citizen who obtained her carry permit. I should be allowed to have my gun on me!

2 Likes