Draft Legislation for Standard 50/50 Custody and Consequences for False Allegations
SECTION 1: TITLE
This Act shall be known as the “Equal Parenting and Custody Accountability Act.”
SECTION 2: PURPOSE
The purpose of this Act is to establish a presumption of equal, shared physical and legal custody (50/50 custody) for minor children following the separation of parents prior to the finalization of divorce. This Act also provides penalties for any party making false allegations with the intent to manipulate custody outcomes in their favor.
SECTION 3: DEFINITIONS
(a) Custody: The legal and physical responsibility for the care and control of a child, including the right to make decisions regarding the child’s education, healthcare, and general welfare.
(b) 50/50 Custody: A custody arrangement where both parents share equal time with the child, and both have equal decision-making authority in regard to the child’s upbringing.
(c) Unfit Parent: A parent who, due to factors such as physical abuse, emotional abuse, neglect, substance abuse, or any other condition that poses a significant risk to the child’s welfare, is deemed incapable of providing proper care for the child.
(d) False Allegation: A claim made in the course of custody proceedings that is knowingly untrue, made with the intent to influence the outcome of a custody determination in favor of the party making the claim.
SECTION 4: STANDARD 50/50 CUSTODY PRESUMPTION
(a) Presumption of Equal Custody:
In the event of parental separation prior to the finalization of divorce, the court shall assume that a 50/50 custody arrangement is in the best interests of the child, unless clear and convincing evidence is presented showing that one parent is unfit to provide care or that such an arrangement would pose a substantial risk to the child’s well-being.
(b) Shared Parenting Plan:
The parties are encouraged to develop a mutually agreed-upon shared parenting plan that reflects equal time and responsibilities for each parent, with provisions for holidays, vacations, and other special occasions. If the parents cannot agree on a plan, the court will impose an equitable arrangement based on the 50/50 standard.
(c) Child’s Best Interests:
The court may depart from the 50/50 custody arrangement only if evidence demonstrates that such an arrangement would be harmful to the child’s well-being or that one parent is unfit. Evidence of unfitness includes but is not limited to: neglect, abuse, substance misuse, or a history of violent behavior.
SECTION 5: UNFIT PARENTS
(a) Definition of Unfit Parent:
A parent may be deemed unfit to care for a child if the parent engages in behavior that threatens the child’s physical or emotional well-being. Such behavior may include, but is not limited to, drug or alcohol abuse, domestic violence, neglect, or emotional abuse.
(b) Burden of Proof:
The party alleging that a parent is unfit must provide clear and convincing evidence of the parent’s unfitness, including but not limited to criminal records, history of substance abuse, or documented instances of abuse or neglect.
(c) Temporary Custody Orders:
If a parent is found to be unfit on a temporary basis, the court may grant temporary sole custody to the other parent, pending the resolution of the case.
SECTION 6: PROSECUTION FOR FALSE ALLEGATIONS
(a) False Allegations in Custody Cases:
Any party who makes false allegations of abuse, neglect, or any other criminal or harmful behavior with the intent to manipulate the custody outcome in their favor shall be subject to legal consequences.
(b) Penalties for False Allegations:
If it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that a party knowingly made false allegations with the intent to manipulate the court’s custody decision, the party making the false allegations shall be subject to the following penalties:
-
A fine of up to $5,000.
-
A reduction in the custody time awarded to the party making the false allegations, including but not limited to a reduction in the parenting time allocation and a presumption of supervised visitation until the parent demonstrates trustworthiness.
-
Potential referral for criminal prosecution for perjury or obstruction of justice, depending on the severity of the false allegations and harm caused.
-
Compensatory damages to the other parent for any costs incurred as a result of the false allegations, including but not limited to attorney fees, expert witness fees, and any other financial damages caused by the false claims.
(c) Burden of Proof:
A finding of false allegations must be based on clear and convincing evidence, including but not limited to testimony, documentary evidence, and expert testimony.
SECTION 7: PROCEDURE FOR CUSTODY DETERMINATION
(a) Initial Custody Order:
When a case of parental separation or divorce is initiated, the court shall issue an initial custody order that includes the presumption of 50/50 shared custody, pending any evidence of unfitness or harm to the child.
(b) Custody Evaluation:
The court may, at its discretion or upon the request of either party, appoint a child custody evaluator to investigate and assess the family dynamics, the ability of each parent to provide for the child’s welfare, and to make recommendations regarding the most appropriate custody arrangement.
(c) Review of Custody Arrangement:
Custody arrangements may be reviewed at any time upon a showing of significant changes in circumstances, including the proven unfitness of one parent or new evidence regarding the child’s well-being.
SECTION 8: ENFORCEMENT
(a) Monitoring Compliance:
The court shall monitor compliance with custody orders, including shared parenting arrangements. A parent who fails to comply with a court-ordered custody arrangement may be held in contempt of court and subject to fines or modification of the custody order.
(b) Adjustment of Custody Orders:
If, at any time, the court finds that a parent is intentionally obstructing the other parent’s time with the child, or if a parent is unreasonably withholding the child from the other parent, the court may modify the custody order to favor the parent who has been obstructed.
SECTION 9: SEVERABILITY
If any provision of this Act is found to be invalid or unenforceable by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining provisions shall remain in effect.
SECTION 10: EFFECTIVE DATE
This Act shall take effect on January 1, 2025, and shall apply to all custody proceedings initiated on or after this date.
This proposed legislation aims to standardize custody arrangements with a presumption of equal time for both parents, while also holding parties accountable for making false claims in custody disputes. It provides a clear structure for determining fitness and penalizing false allegations, ensuring that decisions are made in the best interests of the child and preventing manipulation of the system.