Why Are Beginning Farmers Still Left Out? The Broken Programs Failing to Help New Growers

Access to farmland and resources remains a major barrier for new farmers, even with existing government programs designed to help. To bridge the gap between policy and practice, we need a more unified, farmer-first approach that simplifies access to resources and builds connections with established farmers. One solution is to create a Unified Beginning Farmer Portal, consolidating all federal and state-level programs into a single interface. This portal would offer personalized assistance and streamline the process of applying for multiple support systems, cutting down on bureaucracy and making it easier for new farmers to navigate funding and land access options.

Additionally, we can develop a national mentorship network, pairing beginning farmers with experienced ones. This would provide long-term, in-person guidance, as well as the sharing of critical resources like equipment or facilities. Experienced farmers would receive tax incentives to mentor and share their knowledge, ensuring that new farmers aren’t left to figure things out alone. Building on this, resource-sharing grants would encourage partnerships between new and established farmers, funding joint projects and collaborative use of equipment or infrastructure. This not only spreads costs but also promotes cooperation between generations of farmers.

The Transition Incentives Program (TIP) could be expanded beyond just retiring farmers to allow active farmers to lease land to new farmers while continuing to run their operations. Offering government-backed lease guarantees would reduce the financial risks for landowners and encourage them to lease more land to beginners, knowing their payments are secure even if the new farmer struggles.

New farmers interested in sustainable agriculture should also receive incentives for regenerative practices, such as grants for cover cropping and carbon sequestration, with pathways into carbon credit markets. This would encourage long-term sustainability while providing economic benefits from the start.

To make these programs even more accessible, we can simplify the application process by enabling automatic pre-qualification for multiple funding streams. If a beginning farmer applies for an FSA loan, for instance, they should automatically be considered for other grants or subsidies without needing separate applications. This would cut red tape and make the system more efficient.

Finally, the creation of local farm co-op hubs could provide a platform for new and established farmers to share equipment, market produce collectively, and access storage or processing facilities. These co-op hubs would offer educational resources, legal and financial advice, and facilitate cooperation across the agricultural community. Organizations like the Farm Bureau could play a key role here, fostering connections and ensuring that both beginning and experienced farmers benefit from these shared resources.

By rethinking how we use existing programs and emphasizing collaboration, mentorship, and accessibility, we can create a more supportive environment for new farmers and ensure they have the resources they need to thrive.

8 Likes

The sheer cost of the land where I live is a major barrier to new farmers. Most of our farm land is purchased by the wealthy effectively taking it out of production.

2 Likes

My husband and I are just starting and we thankfully have found someone with 10 acres that rents it to us just so he can have CAUV on his property. We’re trying to find more land to rent and it’s been rough, and we don’t want to bid up or steal a lease from anyone

1 Like

That is fantastic! What kind of farming are you doing? I’m trying to start a hog farm, but can’t find land to buy or rent and has the water I need

1 Like

The acreage we are renting is for crops, this year we did soybeans. We also keep about 5 head of beef cattle in with my parents herd of cows on their property, this was the first year we were able to sell freezer beef!

1 Like

And extend tax credits for farmland purchase to smaller farms! I bought 40 acres and I am struggling with the IRS on qualifying it as farmland. So frustrating. I also submitted a policy and I think our two ideas would mesh together nicely. :heart: I love the portal concept. I keep finding out about available funds or programs after the fact and it is soooooo frustrating. I cannot run my farm AND figure out all these resources.

3 Likes

@PatriciaB @MaraOfWildIdsjelGard,

We just got our beans off last night! We’ll be taking them to the elevator today after work. We’re glad we can use one of my dad’s trucks for hauling!

1 Like

You may need to work with an attorney or accountant. The IRS tax code is complicated.

That looks like a good time to me!

1 Like

Since 1954 Bretton Woods agreement to keep commodity food prices low to keep cities happy and win the Cold War, our own government has destabilized food prices on commodity foods, after 70 years there is no longer much room for movement.
Farmers were forced to subsidize cheap food to the cities. Tighten belts, get more efficient, we lost 6 million family farms in the 1980s to this program. Now only Corporations can pool resources to buy and run factory farms with no people and technology. To break this cycle is to cause massive unrest in the cities as food prices rocket upwards and no government can tolerate this. Also the old people who used the falsely upwards value of their land to keep farming in debt tied to land value can’t sell at $1.00 per acres because then who will take care of them in their old age. So to correct this false value would also bankrupt all the banks, which government can’t accept. So we truly are backed into a untenable situation.

I am a small farmer I will always be a small farmer when I’m okay with that. I will not turn to the government for government money for farming I’m not giving them that interest in my property. However there is something that would be amazing it’s not done on the government level if some tech people could get together and set up a state by state area by area supplies list, or somebody could post on there I’m going to purchase fencing how many people would also like to purchase so we can get it in bulk and get bulk rate pricing. A lady down the road from me I just happened to notice a Facebook post she said hey feed costs are going up really high and they have more than doubled in my area I’m going to order in bulk how many people want to order with me I am so happy for that post because I was able to order feed in bulk with her and it saved me a significant amount. But having something up just for farms and supplies in each area would be great because I just happen to run across that post.

I would also love to see a streamline for veterans and doing away with the $1000 of crops sold for the beginning farmer loan. If anyone can go into a classroom without any education knowledge, just a subject degree, and get emergency certified with a path towards certification, small beginning farmers should get that too. Have a mentorship program. We could have bought land at 2% if I would have lied and said we’d made $1000 off our garden!

1 Like

They’re getting tax credits for that, I regularly get this company trying to get me to put all of my land into a conservation easement I’ll get tax credits and they’ll pay me to not use the land. On the surface that sounds you know awesome till you read the fine print oh and then they tell you how much you’re going to pay which ain’t much. But if I made a fortune and I needed tax write-offs that might be where it’s at.