Proposal for Legislative Reform: Expanding Employment Opportunities, Reforming Expungement Term Limits, and Restoring Gun Rights for Individuals with Minor, Nonviolent Felonies
Objective: This proposal calls for legislative changes to allow individuals with nonviolent, minor felony convictions—such as writing a check with non-sufficient funds—to access employment opportunities in critical sectors like law enforcement, healthcare, education, and other public service fields. Additionally, it seeks to reduce the lengthy waiting periods for expungement of minor felonies and restore the right to bear arms for individuals whose offenses were nonviolent and did not involve weapons.
Background:
In Michigan and other states, individuals with any felony conviction face significant restrictions, even when the offense is minor and nonviolent. Many are permanently barred from careers in certain fields, regardless of rehabilitation or expungement. Additionally, people with nonviolent felonies lose their right to bear arms, a restriction that is not directly relevant to offenses like financial or property-related crimes. The combined loss of job prospects, lengthy expungement terms, and restriction on gun rights prevents individuals from fully reintegrating into society and moving forward in life after a minor mistake.
Rationale for Change:
-
Distinguishing Nonviolent, Minor Felonies from Violent Crimes:
Nonviolent offenses, such as writing a check without sufficient funds, minor drug possession, or petty theft, are typically incidents rooted in situational hardships or poor decision-making, not indicative of any threat to public safety. Imposing lifetime restrictions on employment in public service and denying the right to bear arms over nonviolent offenses fails to recognize the fundamental difference between these minor offenses and violent crimes. -
Excessive Expungement Waiting Periods Inhibit Growth:
Current expungement term limits for minor felonies are excessively long, with individuals often waiting five, ten, or more years to apply for expungement. These prolonged limits hinder people who have reformed from clearing their records and pursuing professional advancement. By reducing these term limits, we would support reformed individuals in building their futures sooner. -
Restoring Gun Rights for Nonviolent Offenders:
People with minor, nonviolent felony convictions lose their right to bear arms, a consequence that is disproportionate to the nature of their offense. For example, a conviction for writing a bad check does not suggest any risk of gun misuse, and restricting gun rights based on this type of offense is an unjust penalty that does not align with the offense committed. Restoring gun rights for nonviolent felons would recognize that the right being restricted is unrelated to their specific offense, supporting fairer treatment and reintegration. -
Potential for Rehabilitation and Community Contribution:
Many individuals with minor, nonviolent felonies have demonstrated personal growth and a desire to serve their communities. However, blanket restrictions prevent them from securing jobs in critical fields, and losing their gun rights further limits their sense of belonging and freedom. Allowing nonviolent offenders to reintegrate without undue limitations would promote successful rehabilitation and community stability. -
Expanding the Talent Pool in Essential Fields:
Public service sectors like law enforcement, healthcare, and education are in need of dedicated workers. By allowing rehabilitated individuals with minor offenses to enter these fields, communities gain from the diversity and empathy that these individuals bring. -
Consistency with Existing Employment and Rights Standards:
Many states already allow nonviolent felons to work in fields like healthcare and education, and restoring their gun rights would align with existing practices in other areas. Extending these policies to public service fields and reviewing gun restrictions based on offense relevance would ensure fairer and more consistent treatment.
Proposed Legislative Changes:
-
Amend Employment Restrictions for Public Service Positions: Allow employment in roles such as law enforcement, healthcare, and education for individuals with nonviolent, minor felony convictions (e.g., check fraud or petty theft), especially if the conviction is older than a specified time period or has been expunged.
-
Reduce Expungement Term Limits for Minor, Nonviolent Felonies: Reassess and lower the waiting period for expungement applications for minor, nonviolent felonies, enabling reformed individuals to move forward in life without unnecessary delays.
-
Restore Gun Rights for Nonviolent Felons: Permit individuals with minor, nonviolent felony convictions to retain or restore their gun rights, as these restrictions are unrelated to the nature of their offense and are thus an unnecessary penalty.
-
Establish a Case-by-Case Review Process: Implement a review process for individuals with nonviolent felonies, taking into account factors such as the nature of the offense, evidence of rehabilitation, and time since the conviction, to assess eligibility for public service roles and restoration of rights on an individual basis.
-
Implement Offense-Relevance Employment and Rights Standards: Assess eligibility for employment and the restoration of gun rights based on the direct relevance of the offense to the position or rights in question. For instance, a financial misdemeanor should not restrict someone from serving in law enforcement or from bearing arms.
Conclusion:
By updating these outdated policies, we can create fairer employment and rights opportunities for individuals who have shown accountability and growth. This proposal supports successful reintegration and acknowledges the distinction between nonviolent, minor offenses and serious criminal behavior. Legislative changes in employment, expungement timelines, and restoration of gun rights would allow rehabilitated individuals to fully contribute to society, strengthening both communities and public service sectors.