Generational requirement for holding a local or federal government position

Overview:

The proposal introduces a requirement that any candidate seeking local or federal government office must demonstrate that their family has been citizens of the country for at least three consecutive generations. The intent behind this policy is to prioritize national cohesion, institutional loyalty, and long-term cultural alignment in policymaking.


Rationale:

  1. National Security Concerns:
  • A generational requirement could reduce the risk of foreign influence or divided loyalties, especially in sensitive national security roles.
  • Generational ties might imply a deeper, more organic cultural integration and familiarity with democratic norms, values, and traditions.
  1. Institutional Stability:
  • Prevents sudden ideological swings based on short-term or external influences.
  • Encourages policymakers to consider decisions with long-term national identity in mind, rather than temporary or potentially foreign-rooted priorities.
  1. Cultural Continuity and Cohesion:
  • Assumes individuals whose families have lived under the nation’s laws for multiple generations are more likely to understand and preserve its founding principles and values.
  • May reinforce trust among constituents that their representatives share a historical and cultural context.

Implementation Considerations:

  • Definition of “Three Generations”:
    • Must clarify what counts as a generation (e.g., parent, grandparent, great-grandparent).
    • Must account for adoption, refugee status, and other nontraditional lineage structures.
  • Proof of Lineage:
    • Candidates would submit documentation verifying their ancestry and citizenship history.
    • May include birth certificates, naturalization records, or other public documents.
21 Likes

As a career military (retired) and civil service employee, I believe this is an exceptional recommendation.

9 Likes

Agreed. The proposal should also be applied to all manners of civil service including law enforcement, with limited carve outs for military only when absolutely necessary. Let’s apply this to welfare as well, turn off the illegal migration magnet.

7 Likes

That’s an interesting thought. Come to think of it, it is pretty crazy that immigrants without citizenship can pull from the welfare pool they have never paid into.

3 Likes

100% agreed but i personally think that it should be 4 generations due to some cultures being very young to have children. Also that they have to prove not only family history but proof they they didnt steal someones identities when they got here like legit green card or somwthing

3 Likes

While this seems like a great idea, I have to ask this…

What about those people who have immigrated legally and become loyal patriots? Dinesh D’Souza comes to mind as well the female Congress person from the former USSR. Both are level-headed patriots that are more knowledgeable about the Constitution than many natural-born citizens in Congress.

1 Like

Promises Made Promises Kept! Thank you President Trump!!!

Make
America
Great
Again!!

:heart::heart::heart::heart::heart::heart::heart:

2 Likes

It appears that the constitutional law requirement you must be a us citizen was violated by Hussain Obama . I believe the punishment must be severe enough to include every person perpetrating the fraud should be considered treason and requires the death penalty.

No, they wouldnt be able to hold office. Thats the whole point of this. They would need to have lived successfully here in this country for generations before they are allowed to control the direction the country goes in. I have a friend who has a second generation child from a legal immigrant, and he seemed pretty upset at me that she would be limited, but it prevents people like the mayoral candidate in new york from happening. If you get hired at a job, do you instantly get a vote in how the business operates?

1 Like

Interesting point. I personally have seen temporary immigrants selling their identity to illegals when they are done here and are ready to go back to their home country.

I think for any normal person trying to sneak in, a perma ban and deportation is enough. As for people who successfully sneak in, and attempt to hold office, yes, death penalty for treason. That would need a very severe punishment to prevent further abuse.

A fair counter. However, can we look at any statistical data for how many legal migrants exploit the system rather than support it and get any sort of proportional data comparison?

I can drive by the welfare office literally anywhere in the state of Colorado, go to any given public place, and can see tens of thousands of migrants exploiting the system, constantly taking, stealing, being rude, being threatening and despising me the regular American guy. They wait in long lines for welfare and free money and it’s rare to ever see them pay at the grocery with anything but welfare ebt cards. Then due to the Jose Illegal vs Joe Legal argument where they get all this welfare and assistance, the guys always drive the dang nicest trucks around, they live in the big houses, have the most kids. While Americans are sidelined.

It’s pretty damned rare to see someone like Dinesh around in real life, even if they’re not famous. In fact I can’t recall the last time I met a migrant in the state of Colorado that I said, boy really glad that person is here. I do however see a lot of burkha’s, see people not speaking english, see homeless Americans everywhere due to job displacement, and see a whole lot of legitimate head to toe tattoo’d up gangsters everywhere just North of Denver these days.

So although the counter is fair, regrettably no. Dinesh and those like him found a successful path and good for them. They can wait. In comparison, my family has been in this country many generations, and I don’t even know, the providence is lost and my grandparents could not answer the question either, back when they were alive. It’s been that long.

And I’m still waiting for a piece of success. Where is my benefit? Can I pretend to be a migrant and get a helping hand or some of that free money myself?

When I was younger I was more fair minded and had open eyes, a bright hope for the future. Now I’m hardened to the iniquities of a monstrously oversized government and an infinitely long line of corrupt people with no integrity always with their hands out getting free money at other peoples expense.

Which is why I have this bumper sticker on my old truck; Work harder, millions on welfare depend on you.

I really don’t care anymore and want so many of these people gone. They’re not real Americans and neither are their children. Many of them hate traditional Americans and our values. They’re here to exploit the system. Entire regions have become virtual no go zones and are not safe anymore. We’ve had enough.

This is a fascinating alternative take on the migration. Migratory plunder.
https://rense.com/general97/reverse-Tide-Mexican-illegals.php

I like your take; When you get hired at a new job, do you instantly get a vote in how the business operates.

Inspired, I’m going to be borrowing this one.

Oh, I’m 100% with you on getting the illegals out! Every. Single. One. Id like to start with Ilhan Omar, who should be deported for immigration fraud. After she has paid back every last dime of the money she earned as a rep.
But the intelligent, patriotic legal ones that have legit become citizens are a whole different story.

1 Like

While I understand your compassion, The opening for infiltration and the ability to change the way of life for the rest of the people living here, I would have to disagree. That’s great they immigrated properly, and are patriotic, hopefully that means they raise grateful, patriotic children, who then create even more grateful, patriotic children, who then can run for office.

1 Like

I believe this woudl be unnecessary, if we had public funded elections, and a free press.
If voters are informed abotu the candidates, and not just fooled with nice ads, then they can choose who they believe is better suited, the recent immigrant, or the multi-generational american citizen.
It’s the peoples choice, but the people need to be informed and not programmed with ads.

I disagree, and fully support you using spell check, or a different translation app. There are active threats from outside this country exploiting our multiculturalism, freedom of speech, and freedom of religion. A generational requirement would minimize the threat of Chinese or Islamic influence, neither of which belong in this country.