The question of what to do with the remaining foreign migrants after deporting the most straightforward offenders has been a contentious issue. My proposal is to grant conditional legal residency to the most eligible migrants while ensuring that the lives of the American working poor are not just preserved but actively improved by the arrival of millions of foreign migrants.
The truth is that illegal migrants entering this country are being granted an advantage that the working poor in America do not have—a clean slate. This means a clear credit history, a spotless criminal background check, and an unblemished rental history. These migrants, often arriving as adults, are given a chance to start over with none of the burdens that hold back millions of hardworking Americans. Meanwhile, the working poor—already struggling under the weight of stagnant wages and limited opportunities—must compete in a job market flooded by new arrivals and face higher housing costs. This disparity is compounded by decades of economic neglect in working-class communities, worsened by the loss of manufacturing jobs following policies like NAFTA in the 1990s. It is unjust that those who played by the rules are left disadvantaged while those who broke them are rewarded with a fresh start.
America undoubtedly needs to deport millions of criminals and other individuals who entered the country illegally. But for those who remain, a blanket amnesty is not a just solution. It is unfair that migrants, having come here illegally, are allowed to start fresh as working adults, free of the burdens of their past. Meanwhile, American citizens are left to face heightened competition for jobs and housing—without the benefit of the squeaky-clean background checks now being handed to these migrants, despite whatever crimes they may have committed in their home countries.
If a clean slate is granted to foreign migrants, it must come with an equivalent benefit for American citizens in the same class. If Washington elites want to grant legal residency to some of the aliens who remain, they must compensate the citizenry for that concession.
Key Benefits for the Working Poor
Any legal measure offering residency to foreign migrants should directly provide the following benefits to America’s working poor:
- Clear Background Checks: A clean background check for non-violent offenses, ensuring working-class Americans have the same opportunity as legalized migrants to start fresh.
- Clear Criminal Records: Expungement of non-violent criminal records, giving the working poor the same second chance granted to foreign migrants.
- Clear Credit Reports: Erasure of bad credit history through federally funded Chapter 13 bankruptcies, financed by a non-deductible tax on illegal migrants over the next decade.
- Clear Rental Histories: Clean rental histories to level the playing field for the working poor in competitive housing markets.
Additional Proposals
- Access to Housing Assistance: Guaranteed housing support, including rental subsidies and mortgage relief, equal to that provided to migrants.
- Debt Forgiveness: Cancellation of non-violent civil debts, such as medical bills and payday loans, to improve the economic standing of the working poor.
- Job Placement Programs: Priority access to job training and federally funded employment assistance programs.
- Childcare and Education Benefits: Subsidized childcare and education grants equivalent to those offered to migrants.
- Driver’s License Amnesty: Clearance of driving penalties for minor infractions to support fair employment opportunities.
- Tax Relief for the Working Poor: Reduced income taxes or refundable credits funded by fees on migrant remittances.
- Community Investment Grants: Direct funding for local schools, infrastructure, and healthcare in areas impacted by migration.
- Legal Aid Support: Federally funded legal representation to expunge eligible records and resolve credit disputes.
- Health Benefits Parity: Public health benefits, including preventive and mental health care, equal to those granted to migrants.
- Financial Literacy Programs: Federally funded initiatives to help the working poor build positive credit histories.
- Debt-Free Name Change Option: Subsidized name changes as part of a clean slate, allowing privacy and a fresh start.
- Nationwide Expungement Campaign: Comprehensive record-clearing initiatives for non-violent offenses.
- Funding for Local Economies: Reinvestment of tax revenue generated by migrant legalization into struggling communities.
- Mandatory Community Impact Fees: Annual fees paid by legalized migrants to directly benefit U.S. working-class neighborhoods.
A Matter of Fairness
The American working poor deserve at least the same economic advantages being granted to illegal migrants, especially the profound opportunity to start over with a clean slate. While public services like housing assistance, healthcare, and education are undeniably valuable, the clean slate itself is the most transformative benefit: a cleared criminal record, unblemished credit history, and spotless background check. This allows migrants, often as working adults, to move forward in life without the burdens of their past—a privilege many struggling Americans can only dream of.
Meanwhile, the working poor in this country face mounting challenges, from stagnant wages to an increasingly competitive job market. They are denied the same opportunities to start anew while simultaneously being disadvantaged by the influx of migrants who often receive job placement preferences based on race or immigrant status. If immigration policies are to be equitable, they must ensure that American citizens are not left behind. Extending the same clean-slate opportunity to the working poor is not just an act of fairness—it is essential for protecting the economic stability of American communities in the face of transformative immigration policies.
The American working class is shouldering the cost of mass migration, often at the expense of their own upward mobility. The influx of millions of foreign migrants into the lower economic tiers of society depresses wages, strains public resources, and raises housing competition, effectively lowering the ceiling for citizens striving to achieve middle-class stability. For decades, policymakers have neglected the struggles of the working poor, treating their economic insecurity as an acceptable trade-off for the perceived benefits of cheap labor. If political leaders and elites are determined to reap the rewards of mass migration, they must also commit to ensuring that the working class is not left behind. A fair and equitable immigration policy must prioritize the well-being of American citizens, offering them the same clean slate and economic opportunities being granted to migrants. Anything less is a betrayal of the very people whose labor built this country.
Footnote: It is worth noting that many illegal immigrants, particularly those who arrive undocumented, effectively begin working in the U.S. with a new name or identity, as they lack official documentation. To ensure parity, the proposal could include granting qualifying American citizens in the working poor the option to legally change their name and Social Security number, providing them with a comparable opportunity to reset their lives and move forward without the baggage of past hardships.
Links: Solar-Powered (Hot) Border Wall: 50x the World's Largest Solar Installation